Our People

Abby Shue

Executive Vice President

I believe in the power of philanthropy to drive meaningful social change, and I’m honored to work with Benefactor Group to support our clients and advance the impact they deliver to the communities they serve.”

Abby Shue

Abby Shue is an accomplished nonprofit executive and trusted advisor with nearly two decades of leadership in philanthropy, fundraising, and strategy. She brings a distinctive blend of first-hand executive experience and consulting expertise—having both led complex organizations and guided clients nationwide through transformational growth. Throughout her career, Abby has advanced mission-driven organizations across the arts and culture, health, human services, and education sectors—helping leaders navigate complexity, unlock philanthropic potential, and achieve lasting impact. 

As Executive Vice President, Client Service at Benefactor Group, Abby leads the firm’s client services team and oversees delivery across fundraising, strategy, governance, talent, and nonprofit technology. She partners with boards, executives, and staff to design practical, data-informed solutions that strengthen fundraising capacity, build organizational resilience, and position nonprofits for sustainable success. Recognized for her ability to coach high-performing teams and foster mission-driven partnerships, Abby consistently helps organizations exceed ambitious goals through collaboration, innovation, and disciplined execution. 

Abby’s expertise spans high-impact philanthropy, campaign strategy, governance, marketing and communications, membership, events, program development, and government relations. She has led six- to nine-figure campaigns, strengthened fundraising infrastructure, and advanced organizations through strategic planning, governance, and executive search. Abby is a Certified BoardSource Nonprofit Board Consultant. 

Client Partners

Publications

  • Giving Magazine, “It’s All About the Soft Skills.” Link.
  • Boardable, “Webinar: Are Your Board Committees Serving You? A Practical Conversation on Committee Effectiveness.” Link. 

Featured Insights

Leading the Pack: Governance Lessons from the Detroit Zoological Society

Leading the Pack: Governance Lessons from the Detroit Zoological Society

March 16, 2026
The Detroit Zoological Society has long been a leader in wildlife conservation, education, and animal welfare, advancing innovative approaches that inspire people to care for the natural world. Strong governance plays a critical role in sustaining this mission, and the organization’s recent work to strengthen its board reflects a commitment to thoughtful leadership and long-term impact. Watch now.

Is There a Generosity Crisis? It Depends.

November 13, 2024
Philanthropy in America has grown at an average rate of 6.5% annually since 1967. The sector has demonstrated remarkable resilience in dollar terms—but recent data shows nuances when it comes to other facets of generosity.
Strengthening Development to Expand Impact at Feeding San Diego

How Feeding San Diego increased individual giving by more than 24%

August 26, 2025
How does a nonprofit turn strategy into measurable results? Ali Colbran, Senior Director of Development at Feeding San Diego, sat down with Benefactor Group Vice President Abby Shue to share how a development assessment and capacity building partnership helped the organization strengthen its individual giving program.
Leading with Intention: Lindy Sayers and the Power of Strategic Governance. Image shows two girls looking up at Buffalo sculptures at the National Museum of Wildlife Art.

The National Museum of Wildlife Art and the Power of Strategic Governance

April 28, 2025
With a deep commitment to the National Museum of Wildlife Art and its mission, Lindy Sayers understands what it takes to be an effective board member. That spirit of intentional leadership was the driving force behind the Museum’s decision to engage Benefactor Group for a governance assessment. As the Museum approached its 30th anniversary in 2017, it marked a natural moment to pause, reflect, and plan ahead. Recognizing that strong, engaged boards are the backbone of thriving nonprofits, the Museum was eager to evaluate and strengthen its boards’ performance. With previous experiences partnering with Benefactor Group, both the executive director and several board leaders knew who to call.  The governance assessment led to meaningful and lasting changes.
Are You Serving Your Board Committees—or Are Board Committees Serving You?

Are You Serving Your Board Committees—or Are Board Committees Serving You?

August 26, 2025
Discover if your board committees add value or create busywork. Download our free self-evaluation to build a stronger, more strategic board.

Louisville Office

Louisville, KY
614-437-3000