Insights

Home » The Benefactor Blog » First of Its Kind: Hiring for a Role Your Nonprofit Organization Has Never Had Before
First of Its Kind: Hiring for a Role Your Nonprofit Has Never Had Before

First of Its Kind: Hiring for a Role Your Nonprofit Organization Has Never Had Before

Picture of Adam Fazio

Adam Fazio

Vice President

You know the moment: Your executive director is pulled in too many directions, the organization needs stronger fundraising results, and members of your team are carrying unsustainable workloads. A new hire starts to look like the obvious answer.

Often, it is the right answer. But a new position is not an immediate release valve. Defining the role, gaining the team’s buy-in, finding the right person, and helping that person ramp up will all take time, and the capacity you’re counting on won’t arrive on their first day.

Here’s what we’ve seen work when nonprofits create a first-of-its-kind role, such as a first Director of Development or Chief of Staff, plus a few thoughts for candidates considering one.

Why Would a Nonprofit Create a New Leadership Role?

First-of-its-kind roles tend to fall into two categories.

Adding a new function

The organization identifies a need for expanding their services, and a new function is a result of that:

  • We worked with an organization that had never fundraised and was ready to hire its first Director of Development.
  • We have also seen organizations expand their services that need to bring on additional technical expertise to plan for and do the work.

Adding new capacity

Sometimes the function exists, but the current structure or team can’t support what comes next:

  • One organization created a Chief of Staff role because it relied too heavily on its executive director for internal and external support.
  • Another was in an extended period of expansion and hired a senior advancement leader to oversee a ten-person development and communications team whose directors had previously reported to a leader without expertise in development, marketing, or communications.

In every case, the strongest decisions start with a plan. Most often, a new role will emerge from a strategic plan, a development plan, or a succession plan.

Before you draft the job description and post a role, it is essential that you know what you’re solving for and why. A role created to ease a pressure point will look very different from one created to advance your strategy.

How Do You Define a New Nonprofit Role and Set It Up for Success?

When a first-of-its-kind hire struggles, the cause is usually a lack of clarity about what the person is there to do and why, followed by unspoken or unrealistic expectations. Thankfully both are preventable.

Start with discovery

Plan for two to four weeks of conversations with the staff who will work most closely with the new role. Peers, the hire’s future manager, direct reports, and in some cases even your board, will have opinions about what they need from this position. Even with a retained search partner, this step takes time, and it’s worth investing the time. You’ll learn what your team expects and where those expectations differ.

Validate what you heard

Share the themes from those conversations back with your team so they can confirm or refine them. Everyone should be on the same page before you talk with a single candidate.

Define what success looks like

For a brand-new role, you probably won’t know the right targets yet. That’s okay. But you should still know which metrics will matter.

How long does it take to hire and onboard a new nonprofit executive?

Once recruitment begins, expect three to four months before someone is actually in the seat. Ramp-up will then take at least three months, and could take six to 12. From the start of discovery to the new hire operating at capacity, the path will often run close to a year or longer.

Support the person once they arrive

A thoughtful start will help your new hire build momentum and keep the role’s purpose clear. Build in:

  • Clear decision rights, so everyone knows what this person owns. A RACI matrix for key decisions and processes can provide clarity for the full team
  • Introductions to key stakeholders, inside and outside the organization
  • Regular check-ins with their supervisor
  • 90- and 180-day reviews of goals and progress

Adding a first-of-its-kind role takes patience. That patience will pay off, whether you are bringing on a new function to the organization, right-sizing roles for your staff, or building a bench to prepare for future leadership succession. At Benefactor Group, we support organizations at every stage of this work: Strategic Planning to clarify the why, Succession Planning to build your bench, Executive Search to define the role and find the right person, and Interim Staffing to bridge the gap while you conduct a search. If you’re exploring a new role, we’d love to talk with you.

Bonus: Are You Considering Applying for a First-of-Its-Kind Nonprofit Role?

If you’re a candidate considering a role that’s new to an organization, you will have a rare chance to build something and make your mark on an organization’s work. You will also have questions that you wouldn’t face if you were stepping into an established role. During your interviews or in conversations with the consultant or hiring manager, ask:

  • How did you determine this role was necessary? The answer will tell you whether the role came from a plan or from pressure.
  • Who participated in creating the job description? You’ll learn how much input the people you’ll work with most closely have had.
  • What does success look like, and how will it be measured? The organization may not be able to tell you the exact targets they expect, but they should have a clear understanding of the metrics for which you will be accountable.
  • How and when will my progress be reviewed? Expect regular check-ins and planned milestones, such as 90- and 180-day reviews.

A first-of-its-kind role can be incredibly rewarding. Asking these questions early will help you step in with the clarity and confidence you need to make an impact.

Email Signup

We take your privacy seriously. We do not sell or share your data. We use it to enhance your experience with our site and to analyze the performance of our marketing efforts. To learn more read our privacy policy.