Insights

Home » The Benefactor Blog » The Legacy Gift That Doesn’t Need an Attorney: A Guide to Beneficiary Designation Gifts
The Legacy Gift That Doesn’t Need an Attorney: A Guide to Beneficiary Designation Gifts

The Legacy Gift That Doesn’t Need an Attorney: A Guide to Beneficiary Designation Gifts

Picture of Paul Yeghiayan, CFRE

Paul Yeghiayan, CFRE

Senior Consultant

Heirs pay income tax on what they withdraw from an inherited traditional Individual Retirement Account (IRA). A charity does not. Your donors can act on that with one form from their custodian and no attorney. Here is how to ask, and what to put in place first.

Why is a Traditional IRA the Best Asset to Leave to Charity?

A traditional IRA is the best asset to leave to charity and the worst asset to leave to heirs. Many donors have never been told this.

The reason is simple. The money in a traditional IRA has never been taxed. The tax comes due when the money comes out. If a child inherits the account, the child pays that tax. If a charity inherits it, no one does, because charities do not pay income tax.

Say a donor leaves a $100,000 traditional IRA to her daughter. The daughter has a good job and is in the 24% federal tax bracket. She has 10 years to empty the account, and since her mother was already taking required distributions, she must take something out every year. All of it is taxable income to her. By the time the account is empty, she will have paid about $24,000 in federal tax, plus state tax in most states. She ends up with $76,000 at most.

The same $100,000 left to your organization arrives whole. You keep all of it.

Now suppose the donor also holds $100,000 of stock and wants to leave $100,000 to her daughter and $100,000 to your organization. She can choose which asset goes where. Stock, a house, or a brokerage account passes to an heir at its value on the date of death, so the gain built during the donor’s life is never taxed. The IRA gets no such treatment.

Leave the IRA to the daughter and the stock to your organization, and the daughter keeps at most $76,000. Leave the stock to the daughter and the IRA to your organization, and she keeps $100,000. Your organization receives $100,000 either way, because it pays no tax on either asset. The only thing that moved is roughly $24,000 that no longer goes to the IRS. The IRA is the asset to give away. The rest of the estate is what to keep in the family.

Three Ways to Name a Beneficiary Without an Attorney

A beneficiary designation is a form the donor files with whoever holds the asset. It decides who gets the asset when the donor dies, and it overrides the will. Most custodians let donors change it online in a few minutes. There is no cost. Three kinds come up most often.

Retirement Accounts

Traditional IRAs, 401(k)s, and 403(b)s all work the same way. The donor asks the custodian or the plan for a beneficiary form and writes in your organization for a percentage or a dollar amount. Donors who have already named their children don’t have to undo that. The form lets them split it, so you might get 10% or 25% and the family receives the rest. With a 401(k) or 403(b), the donor’s spouse may have to sign off. These are the accounts that carry the tax advantage, so ask for them first. A Roth IRA is different. Heirs get it income-tax-free, so the donor should leave that one to the family.

Life Insurance

Many donors hold policies that have outlived their purpose. The mortgage is paid and the children are grown. Naming your organization for all or part of the death benefit takes one form from the insurer, and the gift is often larger than anything the donor could write a check for. Life insurance pays out income-tax-free to anyone, so there is no tax reason to prefer a charity over an heir. The reason is practical. The policy is already paid for, and the need it was bought for has passed.

Donor-Advised Fund Successor

A donor-advised fund (DAF) does not pass through a will. The donor tells the sponsor what should happen to the balance at death. The usual choices are to name a successor advisor, such as a child, to name charities that receive the remaining balance outright, or some of each. Many donors never complete this form. If they don’t, the sponsor’s own policy decides where the money goes, and your organization may not be in it. Ask every DAF donor to name you for a share.

How to Ask, and What to Put in Place First

Start with the donors most likely to say yes. Your QCD donors come first, since they already give from the account you are asking about. Then ask anyone 70 or older whose record mentions an IRA, a financial advisor, or retirement. Then ask every donor who has ever sent a grant from a donor-advised fund. The IRA and insurance donors already have a beneficiary form on file. You are asking them to add a name. The DAF donors may have never filled theirs out, so you are asking them to consider it.

Your legal name, EIN, and mailing address should be on your website where a donor or an advisor can easily find them. The custodian form asks for exactly those three things.

Custodian forms have no place for a gift restriction. If a donor wants the gift to go to endowment or another purpose, ask for a short letter saying so and keep it in the donor’s file.

Decide now who will file the claim. After a death, custodians and insurers require a claim form, a death certificate, proof of your tax-exempt status, and a W-9 before they release the funds. Some custodians also make the charity open an inherited IRA account first, which can add months. The Charitable Gift Planners’ Release IRA Funds Timely (RIFT) Project publishes which custodians require this and sample letters for pushing back. Someone on staff should own that process.

How to Track and Count These Gifts

Record every beneficiary designation as a legacy commitment, as you would a bequest. Note the asset type, the custodian or insurer, the percentage or dollar amount if the donor shared it, any restriction, and the date the donor confirmed it.

Welcome these donors into your legacy society. A beneficiary form is a legacy gift, and you should recognize the donor. Ask for permission before you list their name.

Designations can change, so confirm them. A short note every year or two asking whether the designation is still in place keeps your records current and gives you another reason to thank the donor.

When you report to your board, keep these commitments separate from cash and pledges. They are revocable, and they are not revenue until the funds arrive.

Count the donors who tell you they have named your organization on a beneficiary form. That number shows whether your outreach is resonating with donors.

Many donors review their accounts at year end. A short note asking them to look at their beneficiary forms while they are at it may be the easiest legacy ask you make all year.

Ready to add beneficiary designations to your legacy program? Contact us and our planned giving experts will help you build a plan sized to your organization.

This is general education, not tax or legal advice. Donors should consult their own tax or financial advisor.

Email Signup

We take your privacy seriously. We do not sell or share your data. We use it to enhance your experience with our site and to analyze the performance of our marketing efforts. To learn more read our privacy policy.